Cornwall RSS Feed


Win an iPod

Bovine TB decision a "disaster" say Cornish MPs

9:11am Tuesday 8th July 2008

comment Comments (1)   Have your say »


The Government's decision to do nothing to address the growing crisis of Bovine T.B. in the livestock industry in Cornwall has been described as a disaster' by local Liberal Democrat MPs.

After various trials, studies and investigations, Hilary Benn MP, Secretary of State for DEFRA, accepted that the incidence of the disease is increasing, yet he ducked the decision to announce a cull of badgers in infected areas because it would be generally unpopular in the country. Despite acknowledging that his decision would cause great anger amongst the farming community, Mr Benn offered no additional support.

Colin Breed, Liberal Democrat MP for South East Cornwall and Dan Rogerson, Liberal Democrat MP for North Cornwall, and a member of the EFRA Select Committee which produced a report on Bovine T.B., both attended the Statement in the House of Commons.

Afterwards, Dan Rogerson MP commented: "The Government is presiding over a disaster for the rural economy. Farmers have looked to the Government for action and have been clearly let down.

"Inaction will mean a continuing cull of cattle and a huge social and economic cost to the country.

Falmouth and Camborne MP Julia Goldsworthy added: "Farmers have been waiting for years for this research to be completed, after being assured by the Government that it would act on the basis of the scientific evidence.

"Today's announcement flies in the face of all the evidence and will leave a bitter taste in farmers' mouths.


Your Say YourThis is The West Country

Steve, England says...
11:25am Tue 8 Jul 08

The author of this article obviously wasn't listening to the same statement I heard Hilary Benn make on Monday afternoon. Far from deciding to "to do nothing", the Government has sensibly chosen to abandon a futile exercise which the best scientific evidence shows will at best make things little better, and could even make things worse. Recognising that in the short to medium term the answer to this problem lies in improving cattle management and the TB testing regime the Government has also invited the farming industry to play a part in driving this vital process forward. And recognising that in the longer term the answer is a vaccine, extra money has been committed to boost the chances of success. So much for doing nothing. As for Julia Goldsworthy, she would do well to actually read the scientific evidence. Hilary Benn clearly has done, and has based his policy decision on it.

Comments are closed on this article.

Sponsored Links


Local Advertisers


Local Information

Enter your postcode, town or place name

House prices »   Schools »   Crime »   Hospitals »