Crime fears as Penryn CCTV to be switched off

Crime fears as Penryn CCTV to be switched off

Crime fears as Penryn CCTV to be switched off

First published in Cornwall

CCTV cameras in Penryn town centre will be switched off from April 1 after Cornwall Council's contract to provide the service.

Responsibility for CCTV provision has been devolved to town councils across the county, and Penryn has said it will not be providing an interim service as it considers its options for an alternative system; or the possibility of scrapping coverage for good.

PCSO Lewis Vague, who works in the area covered by the cameras, said: “It's a shame because from a police point of view it's a huge deterrent.

“It helps to catch offenders, whether as part of the identification process or to catch them in the act.

“As a police officer I use it, but it's also a safety thing, and I know if something does happen it will be seen.”

Penryn Town Council had been offered a deal by BT to take over transmission of Cornwall Council's CCTV data on a temporary rolling contract, but chose to decline.

Currently the town clerk is in discussion with their counterparts in Truro and Falmouth, and with Cornwall Council officers, to examine the options for an alternative and less costly system.

Rob Brinkhof, the landlord of the Seven Stars pub in the town centre, said: “It doesn't worry me; I've got my own CCTV which covers the outside and the inside.

“Maybe Penryn Council should use the money to get a private company in.

“They all say it's so expensive but it's not really. There are better solutions to find, probably with the money they could get a better deal.”

Currently transmission of the data costs £8,000, with additional monitoring costs of £5,000, and has been estimated these could be cut by half, however some councillors believe CCTV is not cost effective.

Councillor Martin Mullins questioned the effectiveness of the system. He said: “We discussed how effective the cameras are. Whenever something happens they are pointed the wrong way. Is it a service we don't use?”

Councillor Mark Snowdon agreed, saying it was a lot of money that was going out.

He said: “We could look at other systems at a better price but you have got to do a lot of damage to cover £7,000 or £8,000 a year in the main street.”

However Councillor Cait Hutchings said the council would look “foolish” the council in the event that CCTV was required, asking: “Will we all look foolish together if we cut the cord now?”

It was suggested that a cheap option would be to use the existing cameras, which will remain in place, and to re-route them to the council offices for monitoring, and another option may be to provide funding for local traders to set up their own camera networks.

Comments (3)

Please log in to enable comment sorting

10:27am Wed 12 Mar 14

Gillian R.Z. Martin says...

Councillor Cait Hutchings said "the council would look foolish" "we will all look foolish together."

I do not think the Councillors should care what they look like, providing they make the right decisions for the people and town they represent.

They could have kept quiet about turning the cameras off, and just left them in situ as a deterrent.

Mullion has CCTV covering the park, it has not however prevented someone from melting the top of the recycled plastic picnic bench. (Incidentally, if Cornwall is open for business, why are we purchasing benches from Wales?)
Councillor Cait Hutchings said "the council would look foolish" "we will all look foolish together." I do not think the Councillors should care what they look like, providing they make the right decisions for the people and town they represent. They could have kept quiet about turning the cameras off, and just left them in situ as a deterrent. Mullion has CCTV covering the park, it has not however prevented someone from melting the top of the recycled plastic picnic bench. (Incidentally, if Cornwall is open for business, why are we purchasing benches from Wales?) Gillian R.Z. Martin
  • Score: 2

1:40pm Wed 12 Mar 14

Alanhj says...

If the Councillor's took a 10% cut in their expenses that would probably fund the cost of the CCTV.
A lot of people think it's "Big Brother" but it's not. CCTV can be used a crime deterrent, help I.D. yobs fighting in the streets and be a safety feature for both residents and visitors alike.
To scrap it is madness.
If the Councillor's took a 10% cut in their expenses that would probably fund the cost of the CCTV. A lot of people think it's "Big Brother" but it's not. CCTV can be used a crime deterrent, help I.D. yobs fighting in the streets and be a safety feature for both residents and visitors alike. To scrap it is madness. Alanhj
  • Score: 3

12:43pm Fri 14 Mar 14

Helston fly on the wall says...

Alanhj wrote:
If the Councillor's took a 10% cut in their expenses that would probably fund the cost of the CCTV.
A lot of people think it's "Big Brother" but it's not. CCTV can be used a crime deterrent, help I.D. yobs fighting in the streets and be a safety feature for both residents and visitors alike.
To scrap it is madness.
Town Cllrs don't get set allowances like Cornwall Cllrs so they couldn't give up ten per cent of them. Why should volunteers be out of pocket if they happen to claim minimal expenses for travel or something when required to attend somewhere.
[quote][p][bold]Alanhj[/bold] wrote: If the Councillor's took a 10% cut in their expenses that would probably fund the cost of the CCTV. A lot of people think it's "Big Brother" but it's not. CCTV can be used a crime deterrent, help I.D. yobs fighting in the streets and be a safety feature for both residents and visitors alike. To scrap it is madness.[/p][/quote]Town Cllrs don't get set allowances like Cornwall Cllrs so they couldn't give up ten per cent of them. Why should volunteers be out of pocket if they happen to claim minimal expenses for travel or something when required to attend somewhere. Helston fly on the wall
  • Score: 1

Comments are closed on this article.

Send us your news, pictures and videos

Most read stories

Local Info

Enter your postcode, town or place name

About cookies

We want you to enjoy your visit to our website. That's why we use cookies to enhance your experience. By staying on our website you agree to our use of cookies. Find out more about the cookies we use.

I agree